| Blaine Robinson | University of Louisville | 2019 | |
| Chase Estep | University of Kentucky | 2019 | |
| Reese Sharp | Indiana University | 2019 | |
| Nick Hoffman | Clemson University | 2019 | |
| Mitchell Ayers | Indiana Wesleyan University | 2019 | |
| Jack Walker | Indiana University | 2019 | |
| Jon Vore | Butler University | 2019 | |
| Jack Firestone | Purdue University | 2019 | |
| Kyle Pepiot | Butler University | 2019 | |
| Jack Ellis | John A Logan | 2019 | |
| Jared Green | Butler University | 2019 | |
| Jackson Adams | Butler University | 2019 | |
| Nate Stahl | Indiana University | 2019 | |
| Sam Tackett | Indiana University Kokomo | 2019 | |
| Damon Cox | Northern Kentucky Univ. | 2019 | |
| Avery Short | University of Louisville | 2019 | |
| Bryce Ginder | Indiana Wesleyan University | 2019 | |
| Payton Schofield | Charleston Souther Univ. | 2019 | |
| Clay Holzworth | Butler University | 2019 | |
| Mac Ayers | Ball State | 2019 | |
| John Campbell | Boston College | 2019 | |
| Dawson Estep | Columbia State CC | 2019 | |
| Brock Moore | Rend Lake College | 2019 | |
| Luke Albright | Kent State | 2018 | |
| Kollyn All | Butler | 2018 | |
| Jack Capobianco | Belmont University | 2018 | |
| Cade Carlson | Northwood University | 2018 | |
| Garrett Hill | IPFW | 2018 | |
| Gabe Bierman | Indiana University | 2018 | |
| Drew Rom | Michigan University | 2018 | |
| Casey Maniglia | University of North Carolina | 2018 | |
| Nate Kappers | Indiana University | 2018 | |
| Gage Hughes | University of Cincinnati | 2018 | |
| Keegan Fish | Ohio State University | 2018 | |
| Cole Ayers | University of Kentucky | 2018 | |
| Will Richman | Grinell College | 2018 | |
| Zyon Avery | Ohio University | 2018 | |
| Grant Johnson | IPFW | 2018 | |
| Kyle Music | University of Kentucky | 2018 | |
| Will Phennig | Ohio State University | 2018 | |
| Colten Panaranto | Michigan State University | 2018 | |
| Ethan McCarty | Ball State Univeristy | 2018 | |
| Cameron Swanger | University of Missouri | 2018 | |
| Chase Hug | Olney Central | 2018 | |
| Hayden Jones | Mississippi State | 2018 | |
| Jarred Pohland | University of Louisville | 2018 | |
| Garrett Burhenn | Ohio State University | 2018 | |
| James Quarles | Anderson University | 2018 | |
| Jackson Mitchell | Earlham University | 2018 | |
| Dillon Olejnik | Marian University | 2018 | |
| Tre Waddups | Wabash University | 2018 | |
| Ryan Williams | Morehouse College | 2018 | |
| Brayden DeWeese | IU Kokomo | 2017 | |
| Aubry Major | Xavier University | 2017 | |
| Hayden Wynja | Purdue University | 2017 | |
| Matthew Annee | Wabash College | 2017 | |
| Titen Bennett | Indiana University-Kokomo | 2017 | |
| Alex Cleverly | Bellarmine University | 2017 | |
| Sam Crail | Indiana Unviersity | 2017 | |
| Chandler Ferguson | Northwest Florida State College | 2017 | Cleveland Indians 2017 |
| Travis Gillian | Indiana Unviersity-Kokomo | 2017 | |
| Justin Greene | Gulf Coast State College | 2017 | |
| Kash Hale | DePauw Univeristy | 2017 | |
| Zach Huffins | Arizona State University | 2017 | |
| Brodi Mariotti | Concordia University-Chi | 2017 | |
| Bryce Masterson | Dayton | 2017 | |
| Chris McNally | Wabash College | 2017 | |
| Ryan Metz | Virginia Tech | 2017 | |
| David Nastav | Rose Hulman University | 2017 | |
| Grayson Riekhof | Franklin College | 2017 | |
| Tyler Ward | Air Force Academy | 2017 | |
| Cody Smith | Danville CC | 2016 | |
| Will Smithey | Univeristy of Indianapolis | 2016 | |
| Henry Wannemuehler | Wabash College | 2016 | |
| Jonathan Willoughby | Anderson University | 2016 | |
| Tye Thixton | Danville CC | 2016 | |
| Bailey Buescher | University of Indianapolis | 2016 | |
| Sam Phillips | Ohio Dominican University | 2016 | |
| Robbie Strader | Ohio Dominican University | 2016 | |
| Tyler Blackington | Truman State University | 2016 | |
| Kennedy Parker | Anderson University | 2016 | |
| Justin King | Northern Kentucky University | 2016 | |
| Blake Chitwood | University of Indianapolis | 2016 | |
| Jusitn Reed | Indiana University | 2016 | |
| Peter Hutzel | Washington State College | 2016 | |
| Ben Balogh | Anderson University | 2016 | |
| Milo Beam | Purdue University | 2016 | |
| Luke Buehler | Rose Hulman University | 2016 | |
| Nick Casey | DePauw University | 2016 | |
| Connor Christman | Butler University | 2016 | |
| Nolan Clark | Indiana University-Southeast | 2016 | |
| Harrison Freed | Butler University | 2016 | |
| Kyler Helms | Southern Illinois | 2016 | |
| Donovan Meyer | Angelina College | 2016 | |
| Ryan Pepiot | Butler University | 2016 | |
| Austin Shirley | DePauw University | 2016 | |
| Tucker Waddups | Anderson Unviersity | 2016 | |
| Takahiro Yamada | Dayton | 2016 | |
| Brandon Ward | South Carolina Upstate | 2016 | |
| Nolan Watson | Vanderbelt Univiversity/Drafted | 2015 | KC Royals 2015 |
| Chris Ayers | Indiana State University | 2015 | |
| Sean Casey | Rose Hulman University | 2015 | |
| Luke Miller | Indiana University | 2015 | |
| Caleb Graff | Defiance College | 2015 | |
| Caleb Graff | Asbury Univeristy | 2016 | |
| Ash Russell | Drafted | 2015 | KC Royals 2015 |
| Bailey Partlow | Pasco Hernandez State | 2015 | |
| Bailey Partlow | Indiana State University | 2015 | |
| Braden Girouz | Wabash Balley JC | 2015 | |
| Antonio Lucciola | Lincoln Trail Junior College | 2015 | |
| Owen Young | The Ohio State University | 2015 | |
| Christian Beard | Indiana University | 2015 | |
| Brycen Downs | Manchester University | 2015 | |
| Pauly Milto | Indiana University | 2015 | |
| Zach Spears | Miami of Ohio University | 2015 | |
| Dax McLocklin | Huntington University | 2015 | |
| Darian Dull | Kentucky State University | 2015 | |
| Tron Estep | Elon University (Football) | 2015 | |
| Brian Ball | Notre Dame | 2015 | |
| Tyler Keith | Indiana University Kokomo | 2015 | |
| Jacob Robinson | Indiana University | 2015 | |
| Dax McLochlin | Huntington | 2015 | |
| Brian Mclean | Anderson University | 2015 | |
| Connor Cunningham | Wisconsin-Parkside | 2015 | |
| Matthew Cherhoff | Wabash Valley | 2015 | |
| Nick Maier | Wabash College | 2015 | |
| Grand Sloan | Virginia | 2015 | |
| Garrett Christman | Butler University | 2014 | SF Giants 2018 |
| Chris Elbrecht | University of Louisville | 2014 | |
| Connor Mitchell | Butler University | 2014 | LA Dodgers 2018 |
| Tony Giannini | Ohio University | 2014 | |
| Jackson Freed | Franklin College | 2014 | |
| Trevor Salmon | Univeristy of Southern Indiana | 2014 | |
| Aaron Lemming | Franklin College | 2014 | |
| Ryan Campbell | University of Pittsburgh | 2014 | |
| Darian Dull | Kentucky State University | 2014 | |
| Tyler Langdon | Lincoln Trail CC | 2014 | |
| Nick McCormick | Lincoln Trail CC | 2014 | |
| Brenden Smith | Marian Univeristy | 2014 | |
| Jonathan Bullman | Morehouse College | 2014 | |
| Kyle Fiala | Notre Dame | 2013 | |
| Jack Martin | Eastern Illinois | 2013 | |
| Kevin Rex | Harvard | 2013 | |
| Mitch Roman | Sinclair CC/Wright State | 2013 | Chicago White Sox 2016 |
| Chris Ward | Quincy University | 2013 | |
| Tanner Norton | Western Kentucky University | 2013 | |
| Bryce Pennington | Parkland JC | 2013 | |
| DJ Eckert | St. Joseph's College | 2013 | |
| Andrew Pluckebaum | St. Joseph's College | 2013 | |
| Brandon Calleja | Danville Area CC | 2013 | |
| Curtis Wilson | Danville Area CC | 2013 | |
| Zeth Tanner | Anderson University | 2013 | |
| Kaden Lawson | Indiana State University | 2013 | |
| Cody Compton | Indiana University-Southeast | 2013 | |
| Demetrius Webb | Indiana University | 2013 | |
| Warren Whithaus | Rose Hulman | 2012 | |
| Tyler Anderson | Parkland CC | 2012 | |
| Anthony Asalon | University of Indianapolis | 2012 | |
| Andrew Moralez | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2012 | |
| Matt Dauby | Virginia Tech | 2012 | |
| Colton Elbrecht | Illinois Chicago | 2012 | |
| Ty Urban | Indiana Tech | 2012 | |
| Austin Boos | IL Institute of Technology | 2012 | |
| Glenn Jones | Dayton | 2012 | |
| Donnie Waters | Rose Hulman | 2012 | |
| Ben Breymier | Owens JC | 2012 | |
| Brad Speek | Kishwaukee JC | 2012 | |
| Brice Stratton | Olney Central JC | 2012 | |
| Christian Vukas | Wabash | 2012 | |
| Charlie Dant | Dayton | 2012 | |
| Jason Simpkins | Franklin College | 2012 | |
| Korrie Vire | Webster University | 2012 | |
| Kody Key | Kishawaukee JC | 2012 | |
| Jaylen Quarles | Southeastern Illinois JC | 2012 | |
| Jaylen Quarles | Southern Indiana | 2014 | |
| John Jones | Southeastern Illinois JC | 2012 | |
| Jordan Gard | Southeastern University | 2012 | |
| Jordan Hamilton | Indiana Wesleyan | 2012 | |
| Julian Flanary | Miami (OH) | 2012 | |
| Trey Bickel | Parkland JC | 2012 | |
| Phillip Norris | North Central College | 2012 | |
| Nick Wright | Bellarmine | 2012 | |
| Matthew Deering | St. Joseph's College | 2012 | |
| Mark Downs | Cincinnati | 2012 | |
| Mike Maloian | Thomas Moore | 2012 | |
| Mike McCormic | US Naval Academy | 2012 | |
| Nic Meyers | Franklin College | 2012 | |
| John Eberhardt | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2012 | |
| Connor Hale | Notre Dame | 2012 | |
| Nick McCarty | Notre Dame | 2012 | |
| Eric McKibban | Evansville | 2012 | |
| Adam Neidlinger | Eastern Kentucky | 2012 | |
| Michael Paisley | New Mexico State | 2012 | |
| Donovan Rhodes | Wabash Valley CC | 2012 | |
| Nick Saldutti | Butler | 2012 | |
| Jackson White | Cumberland College | 2012 | |
| Sam Wides | Parkland CC | 2012 | |
| Kent Williams | Indiana University | 2012 | |
| Nick Barrientos | Northwood University | 2012 | |
| Derek Asuras | DePauw | 2011 | |
| Beau Bowen | Seminole State College | 2011 | |
| Matt Bowman | Wabash | 2011 | |
| Clay Clevenger | Vincennes | 2011 | |
| Mike Conner | West Florida | 2011 | |
| Tyler Crace | Gallaudet | 2011 | |
| Dontae Gabriel | Rend Lake Junior College | 2011 | |
| Andy Gehr | Bellarmine | 2011 | |
| Zach Mckinney | Northern Kentucky | 2011 | |
| Terry Mcglothlin Jr | Hiedelberg University | 2011 | |
| Shane Bryant | Indiana Wesleyan | 2011 | |
| Ross Collins | Kaskaskia College | 2011 | |
| Luke Daugherty | Murray State | 2011 | |
| Kyle Rupe | Indiana State | 2011 | |
| Jordan Rinehart | Hiedelberg University | 2011 | |
| Johnathan Higdon | Campbellsville University | 2011 | |
| Jesse Brown | Long Island University | 2011 | |
| Dalton Mallot | Rend Lake Junior College | 2011 | |
| Craig Zupan | Heartland | 2011 | |
| Brendin Hardin | Kaskaskia College | 2011 | |
| Brad Korn | Butler | 2011 | |
| Alex Simpson | Northern Kentucky | 2011 | |
| Kyle Hardacker | Kenyon College | 2011 | |
| Zach Hardin | Kenyon College | 2011 | |
| Andrew Knapp | Taylor | 2011 | |
| Brandon Krieg | Purdue | 2011 | |
| Clayton Marrs | St. Joseph’s | 2011 | |
| Andrew McCafferty | Heartland CC | 2011 | |
| Christian Montgomery | Drafted | 2011 | New York Mets 2011 |
| Phil Mosey | Notre Dame | 2011 | |
| Jack Peck | DePauw | 2011 | |
| Dylan Peters | Texas | 2011 | Marlins 2014 |
| Macklin Runyon | IPFW | 2011 | |
| Jared Ruxer | Louisville | 2011 | Angels/Rangers 2014 |
| Zach Wagner | Birmingham Southern | 2011 | |
| Brandon Wind | Indiana | 2011 | |
| Tony Zunica | University of Chicago | 2011 | |
| Logan Hug | Manchester University | 2011 | |
| Alex Chittenden | Louisville | 2010 | |
| Jarred Clarkson | Louisville | 2010 | |
| Charles Eberhardt | Northern Kentucky | 2010 | |
| Tre Eberhardt | Xavier | 2010 | |
| Ray Stallings | Dayton | 2010 | |
| Mike Maddie | Florida Gulf Coast | 2010 | |
| Nolan Clayton | Lincoln Trail JC | 2010 | |
| Justin Glass | Cincinnati | 2010 | |
| Conrad Gregor | Vanderbilt | 2010 | Huston Astros 2013 |
| Jake Hansen | Purdue | 2010 | |
| Nick Lorenc | Illinois State | 2010 | |
| James Miglin | Toledo | 2010 | |
| Zach Burchette | Anderson | 2010 | |
| Zach Tumulty | Anderson | 2010 | |
| Jordan Turpin | Rend Lake | 2010 | |
| Evan Moncrief | Glen Oaks JC | 2010 | |
| Derek Hannahs | Ohio State | 2010 | |
| Cole Sturgeon | Louisville | 2010 | |
| Codey Harrison | Heidelberg | 2010 | |
| Chase Freeman | Concordia | 2010 | |
| Chandler Sidwell | Coker College | 2010 | |
| Cam Chestnut | Lincoln Trail | 2010 | |
| Austin Clay | Western Kentucky | 2010 | |
| Andrew Byrne | Morton College | 2010 | |
| Brandon O'Connor | Ball State | 2010 | |
| Brad Kindred | Coker College | 2010 | |
| Tyler Holloway | Anderson | 2010 | |
| Matt Jefferson | Northern Kentucky | 2010 | |
| Mitch Overley | Ball State | 2010 | |
| Paul Pistol | DePauw | 2010 | |
| Matt Reida | Kentucky | 2010 | |
| Matthew Ring | Cincinatti | 2010 | |
| Clay Wallace | Central Arizona | 2010 | |
| Joe Wojda | DePauw | 2010 | |
| Tommy Green | Ball State/Marian University | 2010 | |
| Ty Stetson | Murray State | 2010 | |
| Kevin Bower | Miami (OH) | 2009 | |
| Josh Biggs | Evansville | 2009 | |
| Nick Cunningham | Arizona | 2009 | |
| Steve Eberhart | Northern Kentucky | 2009 | |
| Cameron Fagg | Wright State | 2009 | |
| Stevie Gipson-Eberhardt | Northern Kentucky | 2009 | |
| Noah Boswell | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2009 | |
| Kevin Simms | Wright State | 2009 | |
| Jordan Pearson | Indiana State | 2009 | |
| Jesse Moralez | IU Southeast | 2009 | |
| Clint Seefeldt | University of Indianapolis | 2009 | |
| Brooks Fiala | Miami (OH) | 2009 | |
| Zack Galyean | DePauw | 2009 | |
| David Geiger | DePauw | 2009 | |
| Alex Gordon | Murray State | 2009 | |
| Jake Hartley | University of Indianapolis | 2009 | |
| Micah Johnson | Indiana | 2009 | Chicago White Sox 2012 |
| Kyle Lloyd | Evansville | 2009 | |
| Taylor Luna | Taylor | 2009 | |
| Kyle Mason | University of Indianapolis | 2009 | |
| Kevin Plawecki | Purdue | 2009 | New York Mets 2012 |
| Patrick Paligraf | Xavier | 2009 | |
| Chris Pearson | Evansville | 2009 | |
| Jake Roberts | St. Joseph’s | 2009 | |
| Kevin Sims | Wright State | 2009 | |
| Chris Tillery | Earlham | 2009 | |
| TJ Witham | Butler | 2009 | |
| Yante Williams | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2009 | |
| Jacob Weinzapfel | Indiana State | 2009 | |
| Jake Wood | Texas San Antonio | 2009 | |
| Sam Yeary | DePauw | 2009 | |
| Parker Alborher | Birmingham Southern | 2008 | |
| Andrew Armour | University of Indianapolis | 2008 | |
| Alex Berlyn | DePauw | 2008 | |
| Cal Bowling | Ball State | 2008 | |
| Tyler Calder | Purdue | 2008 | |
| Tyler Campbell | Indiana Tech | 2008 | |
| Travis Carsten | Taylor | 2008 | |
| Dominic Catazarite | Ball State | 2008 | |
| Nate Clem | Anderson | 2008 | |
| Mark Conover | Indiana State | 2008 | |
| Pat Craft | University of Indianapolis | 2008 | |
| Justin Cureton | Indiana | 2008 | |
| Blaine Decamp | Butler | 2008 | |
| Hobs Donovan | DePauw | 2008 | |
| Billy Farrington | Indiana | 2008 | |
| Jake Hansen | Purdue | 2008 | |
| Bob Glover | Dayton | 2008 | |
| Mike Green | Bethel College | 2008 | |
| Radley Haddad | Butler | 2008 | NY Yankees 2013 |
| Jeff King | Indiana State | 2008 | |
| Nate Koontz | University of Indianapolis | 2008 | |
| Tyler Koors | Xavier | 2008 | |
| Curtis Matteson | Indiana Wesleyan | 2008 | |
| Joe Neff | Miami (OH) | 2008 | |
| Brandon Stevens | University of Indianapolis | 2008 | |
| Greg Vogt | Anderson | 2008 | |
| Ryan Wides | University of Indianapolis | 2008 | |
| Alex Wright | DePauw | 2008 | |
| Ryan Wright | Louisville | 2008 | Cincinnati Reds 2011 |
| Ty Adams | Notre Dame | 2007 | |
| Bobby Blackford | University of Indianapolis | 2007 | |
| TJ Baumet | Ball State | 2007 | |
| Jimmy Roesinger | Dayton | 2007 | |
| David Dennemann | Butler | 2007 | |
| Jon Clarence | Louisville | 2007 | |
| Kyle Waggoner | Indiana | 2007 | |
| Ross Overstreet | Ohio | 2007 | |
| Eric Charles | Purdue | 2007 | San Diego Padres 2011 |
| Drew Hormann | Miami (OH) | 2007 | |
| Brock Hutzinger | Drafted | 2007 | Chicago White Sox 2007 |
| Zack Kreeger | University of Indianapolis | 2007 | |
| Shawn Marquardt | Miami (OH)/Mississippi State | 2007 | |
| Drew Storen | Stanford | 2007 | Washington Nationals 2009 |
| Matt Westenkirchner | DePauw | 2007 | |
| Dan Black | Purdue | 2006 | Chicago White Sox 2009 |
| Alex Boone | Franklin | 2006 | |
| Travis Capps | University of Indianapolis | 2006 | |
| Andrew Clark | Louisville | 2006 | NY Yankees 2010 |
| Brad Henke | Indiana | 2006 | |
| Austin Nickol | Butler | 2006 | |
| Scott O’Neil | DePauw | 2006 | |
| Matt Speckman | Dayton | 2006 | |
| Jeremy Hazelbaker | Ball State | 2006 | St. Louis Cardnals 2009 |
| Taylor Kinzer | Tallahassee CC | 2006 | |
| Jarrett Casey | Indiana | 2006 | Chicago White Sox 2009 |
| Brad Piatt | Ball State | 2006 | |
| Chris Ulrey | University of Indianapolis | 2006 | |
| Quentin Brown | IPFW | 2005 | |
| Jay Broughton | Ball State | 2005 | Boston Red Sox 2008 |
| Cory Dragstrem | Ball State | 2005 | |
| Tommy Hunter | University of Alabama | 2006 | Baltimore Orioles 2009 |
| Gary King | Indiana State | 2005 | |
| Lance Lynn | Ole Miss | 2005 | St. Louis Cardinals 2008 |
| Justin McManus | Dayton | 2005 | |
| Sean Laird | South Alabama | 2005 | |
| Andrew Madia | Purdue | 2005 | |
| Austin Nickol | Butler | 2005 | |
| Grant Thullen | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2005 | |
| Jason Jamerson | Ball State | 2005 | |
| Nick Shipley | Evansville | 2005 | |
| Pat Tucker | Olney Junior College | 2005 | |
| Joe Ochs | Butler | 2005 | |
| Jimmy Roesinger | Dayton | 2005 | |
| Jeff Alexander | Southern Illinois | 2004 | |
| Chris Comellick | Navy | 2004 | |
| Brian Deter | Butler | 2004 | |
| Kyle McLaughlin | Butler | 2004 | |
| Chris Fetter | Michigan | 2004 | San Diego Padres 2009 |
| Doug Fleener | Indiana | 2004 | |
| Derek Smith | Valparaiso | 2004 | |
| Tony Tevis | Indiana | 2004 | |
| Tony Barnes | Butler | 2004 | |
| Mark Criscimagna | Dartmouth | 2003 | |
| Jon Dages | Butler | 2003 | |
| Mike Dury | Notre Dame | 2003 | |
| Rashard Graves | Indiana | 2003 | |
| Keith Hatfield | University of Indianapolis | 2003 | |
| Ryan Tatusko | Indiana State | 2003 | Washington Nationals 2007 |
| Carlos Paredes | Universidad Santa Maria | 2003 | |
| Julian Brown | Grambling State | 2002 | |
| Matt Bush | Purdue | 2002 | |
| Tyler Ford | Hanover College | 2002 | |
| Aaron Grey | Dayton | 2002 | |
| Mike Lauck | Dayton | 2002 | |
| Justin McCordy | Purdue | 2002 | |
| Joe McSoley | Dayton | 2002 | |
| Adam Smith | Quincy | 2002 | |
| Eric Suddarth | Army | 2002 | |
| Garret Berger | Drafted | 2001 | Florida Marlins 2001 |
| Pat Griffin | Firmin | 2001 | |
| Blake Hibler | Danville CC | 2001 | |
| Bobby Staulbaum | Danville CC | 2001 | |
| Cory Wade | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2001 | Chicago Cubs 2005 |
| Steve Lowry | University of Arkansas | 2001 | |
| Jesse Barber | Kentucky | 2000 | |
| Jim Brauer | Michigan | 2000 | |
| Adrian Brown | Mississippi Valley State | 2000 | |
| Justin Glopsama | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2000 | |
| Kiel Holman | Miami (OH) | 2000 | |
| Jeff Kniptash | Purdue | 2000 | |
| Brian Lortz | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2000 | |
| Steve Lowery | Arkansas | 2000 | |
| Will McConnell | Quincy | 2000 | |
| Paul Richardson | Kentucky Wesleyan | 2000 | |
| Kylan Stuck | Parkland CC | 1998 | |
| Pete Warfel | Kentucky | 1998 | |
| Franco Dotillo | Butler | 1995 | |
| Brian Harris | Mississippi State/ Indiana | 1993 | Philadelphia Phillies 1997 |
